Which broker is right for you? Discount Brokers v/s Full-Service Brokers

by Vivek Bajaj on Basic Finance, Equity Market, Investing Basics
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

— 3 minutes read—

Any transaction in the stock market, whether it is buy or sell, requires a broker intervention.

They work like an agent between the stock market and market participants.

Brokers are registered members of exchanges regulated by the Security and Exchange board of India (SEBI).

There are two types of broker in Indian stock market.

  • Discount Broker

  • Full service Broker

Discount Broker:

Discount Broker offers cheapest, low cost brokerage for buying or selling socks compared to full service broker.

They are technology driven brokers with low operation cost. They only provide trading platform to stock market participants but no advisory means.

When you use a discount broker service you are essentially on your own and you don’t have the added benefit of someone to offer you advices.

The discount brokerage firms’ fee charges are 60% lower in comparison to full service brokers. They also offer free online trading software to all customers.

The most popular discount brokers are Zerodha, 5Paisa and Upstox.

Full Service Broker:

This kind of brokers who provide Research, trading and advisory facilities in stock, commodities, currencies, Mutual fund, IPOs, insurance, Tax tips etc.

They operate from many offices and branches across the country, which client can visit in case of any query.

They offer client dedicated relationship manager, advisory, customized support, portfolio management services, financial planning services, and services relating to wealth management.

The commission charged by the full service broker is higher compared to the Discount broker because the advisory makes up an important part of their cost.

Full service broker provides Companies Fundamental reports and technical calls for investor and traders.

Some full service brokers have their own banking and Demat services account too.

The most popular full service brokers are ICICI Direct, Motilal oswal, Angel broking, sharekhan, Edelweiss Broking etc.

Discount broker vs. Full service broker

Here are the key differences between discount brokers and full service brokers based on different factor:.

broker

Pros of discount stock broker:

  • Lower Cost:- The lower cost is usually the result of lower commission charge compared to the full service broker. It is the primary benefit of using discount broker.

  • Online Trading platform and access of information:- Discount broker is a great fit for those who are comfortable doing their own research. Discount brokers offer best online Trading Terminals free of cost. They also provide education materials like blogs or videos for their clients for financial education.

  • Flat brokerage charges:- Either you are a big player or a small investor, discount broker charge you the same. They offer their clients flat brokerage charges whether you buy 1 lot or 100 lots. For example if you buy 1 lot or 100 lots of nifty, Zerodha charges you flat Rs. 20 whereas full service broker charges you as per % of volume you trade in.

  • Unbiased services and no misleading: Discount broker don’t offer investment advices and have no interest to promote or sell third party product. Thus their clients are not misguided.

Cons of discount broker:

  • No Relationship manager:- In discount brokerage you don’t offer relationship manager like full service broker. So, if you don’t have time to manage your portfolio of stocks regularly and require a person to manage your stocks then discount broker is not for you.

  • No advisory: Discount brokers doesn’t offer research and advisory services, company report and trading calls to their clients. They also don’t provide information on IPOs, FPOs, and Buyback etc.

  • PMS services:- Discount broker doesn’t offer portfolio management services to their clients.

  • 3 in one account:- Discount broker doesn’t offer 3 in one (Banking+ Trading +Demat) accounts. These types of account are only provided by full service banking broker like ICICI Direct, SBI securities etc.

How to decide whether to go with Discount broker or Full service broker:

It is important to select the broker which matches up best with your particular temperament.

  • If you don’t have a lot of money to invest in the stock market and can’t afford to spend large amounts on fees and commissions.

  • You like to do your own research and make your own investing decision.

  • You are good at learning how to use different tools and resources to get the insight you need to make smart decision with your money.

If you find yourself in the following categories, then you should go for discount brokers.

On the other hand:

  • If you are a beginner in stock market and need guidance at every step.

  • You have enough money to qualify for the slightly lower fees that some full service brokers offers to their top clients.

  • You don’t have much time to carry out research and identify suitable trading opportunity.

If you find yourself in the following categories, then a full service broker is good for you.

Key Takeaways

  • If you have enough knowledge, time and are comfortable in making your own decision without any assistance, then discount broker is good for you.

  • On the contrary, if you are new in market and do not mind paying extra commission for the advisory services to save your time, then you can go for Full service broker.

  • The decision of choosing a brokerage house is purely dependent on personal need and preference. A new participant in the stock market must consider the above to take the best decision.


  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

Disclaimer

Elearnmarkets.com wants to remind you that all our content is created solely for the purpose of education. No strategy, stock, commodity, fund or any other security discussed here is any way a recommendation for trading or investing. Elearnmarkets.com will not be any way responsible for trading losses incurred by any individual or entity for trading with real money. Please take advise of certified financial advisers before trading or investing.

Speak Your Mind

*

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.